
I don't normally like to brag but I do consider myself a little bit of a hot dog connoisseur. Therefore I decided to finally answer man's age old question "Who's hot dogs are the best: Nathan's or
Rutt's Hut?". To find the answer, I dedicated last weekend to the hot dog. My quest started Saturday morning. My goal was to eat Nathan's on Saturday and Rutt's Hut on Sunday. This way I would be equally as hungry for each. I left West Chester late morning and trucked on up to Manhattan in my Civic Hybrid. I had to pick up some friends before heading over to Coney Island, the home of the first Nathan's joint and of course to the hot dog eating contest held every July 4th.

Earlier in the I had checked out Nathan's menu on-line and knew what I was going to order before I even got there: 1 Chili dog, a corn-dog (staple of mine), and a Corona Lite (to keep down the calories). My first bite into the Nathan's dog explained why these guys have been around for decades. The dog had a wonderful snap to it and the chili had a nice subtle flavor. I was hooked. Feeling like I gave them an fair shake, I then proceeded to ride the Coney Island Cyclone, power down a fried Snickers...and a fried Twinkie, before finishing my day at Coney Island by playing "Shoot the Freak". I paid $10 bucks to shoot a "freak" with a paintball gun. That was fun. I wonder what they pay the "freak".

Sunday morning I awoke in my buddies apartment on the Upper East side of Manhattan giddie with excitement to try Rutt's Hut. Rutt's Hut is located in Clifton, NJ. For those of you who have never heard of Rutt's Hutt, they are famous for deep frying their dogs. They are so famous that the Travel Channel, PBS and the Food Network have all done multiple shows on them. I had to go and figure out why.

I arrived at Rutt's Hut at around 11am. The place was a bit quiet as I had just beaten the lunch crowd. This worked out perfectly because I was able to meet the manager and he was kind enough explain everything about their Rippers (hot dogs). The name Ripper refers to how the dog's skin cracks open in the deep fryer. As far as I can remember, you can order your dog in the following ways:
1) In and outer. The dog is only put into the fryer for a second to warm it up
2) Medium. A little longer
3) Well Done. A little longer
4) Cremator. This is where it gets a bit more interesting. The dog is kept in the fryer so long that the out skin gets a bit crispy and almost has the consistency of crispy bacon. Oh baby, come to papa.
After the explanations I was left with no ther choice but to try them all. As the Cremator takes a bit longer to cook, I was first served the others. To compliment the dogs, Rutt's Hut provides a nice delicate mustard and an incredible relish. The relish is unique that it does not overpower the taste of the dog. I loaded all of my dogs up with a lot of both. I can't begin to explain to you how happy I was at that moment. And, when the Cremator was finished I only got happier. I started ordering more dogs and in the fog of war I actually lost count on how many I ate. I do believe it was in the neighborhood of 5 or 6.
So now for the verdict. In terms of pure taste, I will say that both joints offered a fantastic hot dog. They were both so good that to choose between the two would be like picking your favorite Weiss Beer. Therefore, we will call the tastes even. However, if you were to ask me which one I would go back to first....well thats easy, Rutt's Hut. There is something special going on in Rutt's Hut. You simply cannot get a better hot dog for less than $2. The taste, combined with the style of the joint, combined with the reasonable price, combined with the owner who was cool enough to give me a little history about the place makes this one of coolest places I have been.
P.S. After eating the hot dogs I went down to the Philadelphia Bike Race where my buddy cooked up some sauerkraut and hot dogs. Those were pretty darn good too!